Portobello Town hall Concert
In April 1967, St John’s Parish Church in Portobello, Edinburgh, held a celebratory concert at Portobello Town Hall, to mark and honour their ex choir-master, Father Curran, who had just been ordained into the Catholic Church.
The contributors to the concert were:
- Pat O'Brien The Presenter and Master of Ceremonies
- The men’s choir - featuring John McElroy (lead tenor) and Bill Hunter (lead bass)
- The boy’s choir - featuring Paul McElroy (lead soprano)
- Paul and Stephen McElroy, a folk group (John’s sons) and members of the choir
The concert hall (capacity 466) was packed with parish members and Portobello community residents.
A tape recording was made of the concert and converted into a vinyl LP, which had limited distribution within the local community.
Unfortunately, it is a poor recording. It sounds like the recorder (I hesitate to say engineer) used just a single, cheap tape-recorder microphone, positioned at the back of the hall, to record the concert end-to-end. The tracks are full of background hum. Words - spoken and sung - are difficult or impossible to make out and the overall sound is tinny, remote and full of echoes.
Sorry for such a damning critique, but I thought it best to prepare and set your expectations before you listen to it.
Having said that, there are some magic moments:
- Like my Dad and Bill Hunter as the Bold Gendarmes singing “We Run Them In”, from Act 2 of Offenbach’s operetta, "Genevieve de Brabant", with the libretto translated into English by Henry B. Farnie.
- At the point where the audience laughed nervously, when Paul and I sang “The Merry Ploughboy (an Irish rebel song) and proclaimed the words: “We’re off to join the IRA, and we’re off tomorrow morn” (we were 13 and 12 years old respectively, at the time).
Overall, there is a beautiful quality to the singing which shines through as a wonderful delight (notwithstanding my deprecatory opinion of the recording):
- Both Choirs - boys and men
- John McElroy
- Bill Hunter
- Paul’s singing (Paul also sang in the famous Westminster Boy’s Choir)
- And dare I claim, Paul and I performing to a large audience as The Kinsmen for the first time
A long-standing side project of mine is to use digital audio-processing tools to clean up and repair the audio. Hopefully, I will find the time soon to do this.





























